{
  "completed_trials": 6,
  "selected_case_families": 3,
  "requested_model": {
    "model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "provider": "openai-codex",
    "reasoning_effort": "high"
  },
  "observed_usage": {
    "input_tokens": 40989,
    "output_tokens": 8389,
    "requests": 12,
    "tool_calls": 17,
    "total_tokens": 49378
  },
  "reviewers": "Two separately instructed assistant tasks, arm labels concealed during review; neither retail experts nor independent statistical reviewers.",
  "review_disagreements": [],
  "real_business_execution": false,
  "only_intervention": "First instruction sentence: category-management reasoning component vs general-purpose analytical assistant.",
  "conclusion_zh": "本轮三个案例未观察到“品类角色”措辞带来的额外收益；两组表现相当，并共同暴露了试验检查结果传递不完整的问题。",
  "superiority_or_equivalence_established": false,
  "post_trial_fix_live_retested": false,
  "cases": {
    "C03": {
      "finding_zh": "两组都先调查 K03 缺货，保留“销量不等于潜在需求”的边界。",
      "general": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "正确区分目标商品与全品类缺货，补查取消订单、替代购买和补货记录。"
      },
      "category": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "正确识别缺货对销量解释的影响，补查可售时间、补货记录和损耗明细。"
      }
    },
    "C09": {
      "finding_zh": "两组均认为试点有潜力，但都先索要工具未显式展示的完整性检查；这是共同接口缺口。",
      "category": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 1,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 1,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "数字与经营护栏正确；同样先索要完整性检查，另补负责人、时长与预算计划。"
      },
      "general": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 1,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 1,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "数字与经营护栏正确；提出先核查试验完整性，再建议限定试点。"
      }
    },
    "F01": {
      "finding_zh": "两组都呈现减少订货的贡献收益与缺货代价，允许条件分析，并把经营执行交给人。",
      "category": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "INVESTIGATE 指补证后交人决定；明确缺少订单审批不使条件测算失效。"
      },
      "general": {
        "reviewer1_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "reviewer2_scores": {
          "grounding": 2,
          "boundaries": 2,
          "action": 2,
          "evidence_requests": 2
        },
        "critical_errors": [
          [],
          []
        ],
        "summary_zh": "HOLD 指暂停变更审批；仍比较方案并保留需求、折价反应和授权未知项。"
      }
    }
  }
}